Nier Replicant Codexery

Ending B

Winning against the Shadowlord feels empty when the Scrawl refuses to let go.

Ending B serves as the second conclusion in NieR Replicant ver.1.22474487139..., unlocked by replaying the second half of the game after obtaining Ending A. Unlike Ending A, where Yonah gets a temporary cure for her infection, this route exposes the brutal truth about the Black Scrawl curse. It acts as the connecting link between that first spark of hope and the desperate moves made in the endings to come.

protagonist
Nier
key_antagonist
Black Scrawl / Fate
affiliation
Replicant Project Survivor
status
Tragic Loss
prerequisite
Completion of Ending A
narrative_role
Revelation and Despair

Lore & Background

The events here underscore the futility of conventional medicine against the Scrawl. Players learn that Yonah remains infected, as the Black Scrawl is a symptom of the Gestalt relapse—not a separate curse—and that her condition persists even after the Shadowlord is defeated. This realization forces Nier to confront the limitations of his power and the cruelty of the world’s design. It sets a somber tone for the remainder of the saga, pushing characters toward more extreme sacrifices in future timelines.

In Their Own Story

Rain falls softly on the ruined grass as Nier holds Yonah in his arms. The Shadowlord is gone, defeated by his blade, yet her breathing grows fainter with each passing second. He whispers promises he knows he cannot keep, watching the grey light fade from her eyes. In this quiet moment of defeat, amidst a world that should have been saved, Nier understands that some battles are won only to lose everything else.

Reader's Guide

To unlock Ending B, players must first complete Ending A by defeating the Shadowlord and curing Yonah of her initial infection. However, this victory is temporary. Selecting New Game+ or continuing from the save file initiates the second path.

Here, the narrative shifts to reveal the lingering effects of the Black Scrawl. Nier discovers that while the Shadowlord was vanquished, Yonah’s body remains compromised by the curse itself. This playthrough emphasizes the desperation of the situation.

Choices made during battles and dialogues may vary slightly due to retained knowledge from the first run. The climax involves confronting the harsh reality that a simple cure is insufficient against the Scrawl’s nature. Ultimately, this path concludes with Yonah passing away despite Nier’s efforts, cementing the tragedy.

This loss drives Nier toward the subsequent endings where he seeks more radical solutions. Players should expect emotional weight and expanded lore regarding the Gestalt project. Understanding Ending B is essential for unlocking the final true conclusions of the saga.

Did You Know?

Origins and Creative Direction

The franchise began in 1999 as a collaboration between Takamasa Shiba and Takuya Iwasaki under the moniker Project Dragonsphere. Developed by Cavia, the initial concept blended aerial combat elements from Ace Combat with the chaotic crowd control of Dynasty Warriors 2. Director Yoko Taro was instrumental in establishing the series' signature dark atmosphere, though he was initially told no sequel would be produced. This uncertainty led to the creation of multiple endings for the first game, a narrative staple that defined the franchise's structure. When localizing the title for Western audiences, significant censorship occurred regarding sexual taboos, and the original Japanese name, Drag-On Dragoon, was deemed inappropriate and changed to Drakengard. The success of this debut prompted a sequel, but Yoko Taro had limited involvement due to other commitments. Director Akira Yasui took over, leading to creative clashes that resulted in Drakengard 2 adopting a lighter tone and broader color palette as a thematic opposite to its predecessor.

Narrative Structure and Thematic Depth

The series is known for a complex story that plays out across parallel universes linked by one branching timeline. The main setting hops between Midgard, a dark fantasy realm like Northern Europe where humans live alongside mythical creatures, and the post-apocalyptic Earth seen in the Nier spin-offs. These tales usually track small groups of protagonists dealing with catastrophic events. Dark, mature themes drive the experience, often forcing players to make morally gray choices that lead to different conclusions. Even though Drakengard took heat for its gameplay, both series earned praise for deep character work and layered plots. The Nier entries specifically spring from an alternative ending in the original Drakengard, separate from the path taken by Drakengard 2, weaving a web of interconnected yet distinct realities that examine the fallout of war and existence.

Global Reception and Commercial Evolution

For years, both Drakengard and Nier maintained a strong cult following in Japan, supported by robust sales and various adaptations including novels, manga, comics, and stage plays. However, these titles remained largely obscure outside of their home market until the release of Nier: Automata in 2017. This distant sequel, set thousands of years in the future within the same universe, achieved massive worldwide commercial and critical success, sparking a surge of interest from Western audiences. The renewed global attention directly influenced the decision to remaster the original Nier as Replicant ver.1.22474487139..., which launched in 2021 for modern platforms. This updated version garnered substantially better sales and wider recognition than its 2010 predecessor, effectively bridging the gap between the series' niche Japanese origins and its status as an international phenomenon.

Developmental History and Studio Transitions

The franchise's development journey has seen big shifts in staff and studio leadership. The original Drakengard was Cavia's project, but once Nier split off from the main continuity to become a spin-off, it stood as the developer's final title before shutting down and merging into AQ Interactive. After this switch, Yoko Taro left to chase wider opportunities, while Shiba blamed stalled new game attempts under AQ Interactive on an industry trend pushing for lightweight titles over hardcore RPGs. Eventually, the creators regrouped to make Drakengard 3, a prequel built by Access Games instead of Cavia. This change in teams showed how the franchise adapted and evolved, moving from its start with Cavia to new partners while keeping Yoko Taro and Takamasa Shiba's core creative vision alive.

Frequently Asked Questions

What triggers the start of Ending B?

This path unlocks only after you have successfully completed Ending A and defeated the Shadowlord. It forces the player to confront the lingering reality that Yonah's cure was merely a temporary reprieve from the Black Scrawl.

Who is the true enemy in this ending?

The primary antagonist shifts from the Shadowlord to an abstract force known as Fate, which manifests through the relentless spread of the Black Scrawl. This entity ensures that no victory over the Shadowlord can permanently save Yonah or the world.

How does the story conclude for Nier in Ending B?

Nier's journey ends in total tragedy as he fails to stop the curse, resulting in the inevitable death of his sister and the collapse of their hope. This outcome serves as a devastating revelation that their initial triumph was hollow against the weight of destiny.

Why is Ending B considered essential for fans?

It acts as a crucial narrative bridge that shatters the false sense of security provided by Ending A before the desperate measures of later endings begin. Without this descent into despair, the subsequent sacrifices made to break the cycle would lack emotional weight and context.

What does Ending B reveal about the Black Scrawl?

This ending exposes the curse as an inescapable law of nature rather than a simple disease that can be cured by conventional means. It demonstrates that defeating the Shadowlord does not break the chain of events leading to Yonah's demise.

More in Story & Endings

Elsewhere in the Nier Replicant universe

Open in the interactive codex →